Does Wick Size Really Matter? Why Your Candle’s Burn Depends on It

December 6, 2025

The title might give you a little smile, but don’t worry — we’re keeping things completely wholesome here. We’re talking about candle wicks, and yes… wick size truly does matter. The right wick size affects how your candle burns, how well it releases fragrance, how long it lasts, and even how safe it is. Let’s break down the science behind wick sizing — and why it makes such a big difference in the candles you enjoy at home.

🔥 What Does Wick Size Actually Mean?

A wick isn’t just string.
Its thickness, braid style, and fuel flow determine how large the flame becomes and how efficiently the wax melts.

When a wick is correctly sized for the candle:

The flame stays steady and appropriate in height
The melt pool reaches the jar edges without tunneling
Soot is minimized
The candle lasts longer
The scent throw is rich and even

When it’s the wrong size?
Well… that’s when the problems start.

⚠️ What Happens If the Wick Is Too Small?

A wick that’s too small struggles to pull wax up the wick fast enough to fuel the flame.

This can lead to:

Tunneling (the wax melts straight down, leaving wasted wax on the sides)
Weak scent throw
Flame flickering or self-extinguishing
A candle that seems to “not work right”

Even the best fragrance and wax blend can't perform if the wick is too small.

⚠️ What Happens If the Wick Is Too Large?

A wick that’s too big burns too hot, causing:

Excessive soot
Overly large flames
Rapid wax consumption
Fragrance evaporating too quickly
Potential jar overheating (never good!)

This is why wick testing is one of the most important — and time-consuming — parts of making a candle that burns beautifully.

🧪 How We Choose the Right Wick at Wax & Warmth

Every wax type, fragrance oil, dye load, and jar style needs a wick that matches its burn characteristics. There is no such thing as one universal wick size that fits all candles — every batch requires careful testing.

For our candles, we use:

9 oz straight-sided glass jars
Coconut–soy wax blend
Clean and Prop-65-compliant fragrance oils

Try Grandpa's Pipe. Its one of our top sellers! https://waxandwarmth.com/products/grandpas-pipe-sweet-tobacco-candle

Through extensive testing across fragrances, temperatures, and burn cycles, we selected a wick size that delivers:

A steady, controlled flame
Beautiful edge-to-edge melt pools
Minimal soot
Clean jar walls
Strong, consistent scent throw

It took a lot of test burns and adjustments to find the sweet spot — but the result is a candle that performs reliably whether you burn it traditionally or warm it under a candle lamp.

(We don’t list our exact wick size publicly — that’s part of our formula — but rest assured, every batch is tested before reaching your home.)

🌬️ Why Wick Size Affects Scent Throw

Fragrance release depends heavily on how the wax melts.

Too small a wick = melt pool too shallow → weak or uneven scent
Too large a wick = wax vaporizes too fast → scent disappears prematurely

A perfectly sized wick creates an ideal melt pool depth of about ¼" to ½", which is where fragrance oils are released most efficiently.

🧹 Wick Size + Wick Trimming: A Team Effort

Even with the correct wick, trimming still matters.

Always trim to ¼ inch before each burn
A wick that’s left too long can burn hotter than intended
A wick trimmed too short can drown or struggle

Think of trimming like tuning an instrument — it helps the candle perform exactly the way it was designed.

🔥 Wick Size and Safety

Proper wick sizing isn’t just about fragrance and aesthetics — it’s also about safety.

A well-sized wick helps prevent:

Overheating
Jar stress
Excessive flame height
Rapid wax consumption

This is why every candle we make undergoes multiple test burns. Safety and consistency are non-negotiable.

🏡 Final Thoughts: Yes — Wick Size Really Does Matter

It matters for:

Burn quality
Scent throw
Candle longevity
Safety
The overall experience

So the next time you enjoy one of your Wax & Warmth candles, you can relax knowing that a lot of science, testing, and careful selection went into a wick that’s perfectly matched to your candle — and designed to give you the best burn possible.

Explore Our Clean-Burning Candle Collection

Browse all hand-poured coconut–soy candles designed for long, even burns:
👉 https://waxandwarmth.com/collections/all-products

See the below links for more information on Candle Warming Lamps, and How to safely fix candle tunneling.

https://waxandwarmth.com/blogs/blog-1/candle-warming-lamps-how-they-work

https://waxandwarmth.com/blogs/blog-1/how-to-fix-candle-tunneling

Back to blog